BILL HILL, the man is 65, wise, tough lover and a survivor. He has delivered 7 babies so far, 2 in Woodstock of which he said "I didn't know they were pregnant enough to have babies", his 2 daughters, 2 that had complications, and the last one to his neighbor Mary. Mary had her home birth secretly because doing such is illegal in New Orleans (along with 15 spectators, Bill says she started completely dressed but halfway ripped her clothes off with everyone there,” it’s natural ya know?"). Bill learned how to deliver babies through experience with cows, dogs, cats and reading one birthing book, simply observing the diagrams and noting the important signs of the mother’s status and that of the baby. "It's not rocket science, it’s nature." When Bill speaks about the birthing of his wife he said, "she just pushed it out, but I did most of the work", when previously he had stated if there aren't complications all there is to do is catch it. I believe such contradiction and prejudice towards the strength of his wife comes from the fact that she left 3 weeks after the birth of their second daughter. I found this prevalent to the analysis of Bill's point of view on such a subject because he became the mother and the father, he had to buy his daughters first bra in the middle of a snow storm because her nipples were showing. Bill was brought up his first 18 years of life in the foster care system (essentially a slave), this is interesting because he became a mother in such prevalent ways and so close to the process of women without ever having a mother or sister of his own. Bills second daughter was born with dislocated hips and he eventually found a hospital (the Shryner club) that was willing to aid in his daughter’s treatment (she grew to eventually have no effects of the birth complication, but had steel in between her feet for the first few months). Because of the abandonment of her mother Bill was desperate to find an alternative to formula for his daughter, and she was breast-fed by the neighbor for a whole year! (My grandpa’s mom when she had kids had HUGE amounts of breast milk, so she would pump and give the rest to the hospital) Bill says the most important factors of birth are insuring the baby is in the right position and is not wrapped by the umbilical cord, he has dealt with both of these issues. One of the babies head was wrapped by the umbilical cord so he pushed it back up, stuck his hand in her vagina, unwrapped it, and out the baby came. Mary from New Orleans was having great difficulty so he made her teas, drew a warm bath (with Epsom salt) in she went and 10 minutes later the baby came out, but his hand was by his head so he pushed him back in and then out he came. Bill says he's learned through sex and one book, that rubbing women’s nipples helps vastly with the facility of birthing. He also says what is very important is the after care; making sure the women hasn’t ripped, all the placenta is out, she is clean, and so is the baby. Bill says he hates the modern birthing industry and the manner in which hospitals complicate births and enforce their practicality and profit versus the comfort of the mother. He says cesareans are simply rushing the mothers, and alters the women’s body and experience when unnecessary. "old days it was the natural way, ya know". Bill says delivering a child is the most invigorating experience he has ever had, seeing the baby take its first breath, slapping it on the butt, wiping its nose, making sure it is okay, "not to many people get to do that". I find Bill is a great example of "with age comes wisdom". I respect him so very much, and for the short time I spent with him learned a lot and connected deeply. Bill ended saying two things I found very powerful "Life is a bunch of cycles, you cycle through it, then your gone." Describing birth and injustices created through mother culture "Just the start of a life, Just the start of a life, we just gotta break the cycle, we just gotta break the cycle." I believe the stories of each birth (which I did not write because of time restrains) were ultimately what stuck with me the most. The connection and struggle of the women that I could feel within me, the relation of the budding of a new organism to continue to sprout around all our influence. Of these Mary's was the most powerful, she was defying the state law in order to under go the most instinctual natural process and doing it with out the restraints of the industries. I could imagine it, a warm home glowing with light radiating from the mood and feelings of the 15 expectant lovers, radiating their feel along with the mother. Sitting with struggle, chained in by her clothing, embracing her skin tightly, struggle, more sweat, more pain. Ripping off her clothing, her beautiful brown body radiating of life, a tight stretched belly falling towards the ground, a beautiful back and smooth skin, a red and present face strutting around the house. This symbolized for me the ultimate women’s empowerment her being the center of attention because of her struggle in her most animal form naively being, not restricted by the pressures of society, with as many people as she desired supporting her. Bill's experience with birth completely defies that of most people in America, his relation with American women, and their process as well. Bill's view goes against the mainstream business of birthing.
RYAN MADOOR is 29-year-old women with 3 kids, 8&7 year old, and an 18-month year old. Ryan went through all the phases; she had a predominant American hospital birth, the first with epidural and patosen for enduced labor, the second only and epidural. Her last child was born all natural with a doula but was simply conducted in a hospital (the effects of her ever lasting fear instilled by society). Ryan says she remembers all her births equally and felt the same joy but felt EMPOWERMENT such that she could not put in words from her natural birth. She used breathing techniques, strattled her bed and would focus on a certain point and would breath as deeply as she possibly could into the pain letting it out through all her extremities. (I could imagine these women completely extended with each wave of energy and tension rushing through her body jaggedly but exiting with sensual calmness.) When she was fully dilated she gave birth standing up and they placed cushions beneath her to soften the crash of the child. In such an experience Ryan said she had a change of personality and learned allot about herself and her personal boundaries. With each birth of her children she progressively learned more and de-mystified the subject while learning more about herself. She said she felt society was trying to dis-empower the women and take such an experience and turn it into one of profit motive. The birth of her first child cost $13,000 the second $10,000 and the last $5,000. With her first birth she said the patosen freaked her our because she lost control of her emotions because of the rapid occurrence of her reaction in her body and was no longer in control, she also said their was no one to help coach her through the pain. With the second child she had strong feelings of excitement and less of fear and anticipation of the unknown but still felt repressed by the staffs response to her. She feels all the fears and stigmas she had against birth stemmed from mass medias strong structure of having to do A. B. C. D. with no option. She feels society builds in a fear factor for birth to create the dependency on the industry versus educating the mother. Ryan says she has a fear of having kids late and life and is one of the reasons she had them so young (she wants one more), she wants her children to have great-grandparents, wants to be able to run and play with her children. She questions the dominant social practice of having children later in life and wonders the effects it has on the child, and oddly the economy.
VALERIE BURDIN (MANMAN), this was an odd interview because my mother’s answers were quite dry and redundant for the most part. As far back as I can remember I would always ask my mother the story of my birth over and over, always asking something new. Yet it still gave me such as sense of joy and overpowering love and connection to my mother, such that her answers we dry because in a sense my body and unconscious thought knew the answers of these already. Not in concrete statable memories, but in that of emotion and feeling (the sense of being aware in which my bodies nerves move). My mother had me at 33 years old in St. Raphael a small town in the south of France. She surprisingly had a cesarean (even though she did all to avoid it by getting a homeopathic vaccine a month before, because she has a vaginal condition) because I was facing outwards instead of having my skull first. BOY WAS I ALERT ALREADY, READY TO BE NOTICED! (HAHAHA) The cesarean was not rushed or forced; it was simply done in a relaxed manner, after a while for the best of my health. During her cesarean the doctor (whom also delivered all my aunts, and cousins) narrated the event for my mother and then the nurse placed us head by head "on se embrase pour la premier foi"(to make out for the first time.. truly in-translatable like a lot of French). She says she did not read any books or buy any gadgets or extra preparing she says "ya pa de tous ca!" In France having a child is supported by the government, unlike America where it is practically discouraged! First the government covers everything, the mother can choose to give birth in a hospital or a clinic (the equivalent of a private hospital, smaller and less regulated). At the beginning of the 6th month of pregnancy the parents are given money every month, (first month she bought bed, next stroller, ect.) in France we do not have baby showers there is no need for everyone to help you with the expenses and cover it up with an exhausting stressful party for the mother. The mother receives a mid-wife, which conducts 3 lessons post birth to teach you the logistics, and is connected with the mother’s choice of doctor so they are exchanging information. The government suggests that you stay in the hospital for a minimum of 5 days so you can RELAX!!!! Over the course you learn how to breast feed, shower the baby so on. You are given the option to keep the baby in your room at night or they can keep the baby over night so the mother can get her rest. After your birth for the first 3 months the governments provides time off from work, paid full salary; the women receives more time if she is breast feeding. The government also provides for both parents a year off from work where you are only paid the minimum monthly wage, but your employer is obliged to take you back after your leave. The Government also has public nursery’s that have good prices so that if necessary their is the option to have a baby care taker. I focused on the logistics of government support because it shows the vast difference between America and France and exemplifies the cruelty and dis-empowerment placed upon women by the American system. Also seen with the comparison of Ryan's experience shows how mechanical and industrial the process becomes in America, just another business investment. Where as France even though an industrialized society supports the nature of a women and not being completely oblivious and suppressive to our animal habits.
Questions and main interest I have developed from these interviews are: How can we break the cycle? How has the DSP of having children later in life affected the women, child, and family’s life? How do the DSP’s in America around pregnancy and birth dis-empower women?
Eloise! First my apologies for this post being late...my day blew up in my face and i just couldn't get to it until now.
ReplyDeleteFor me the most stimulating point here is about the cost of childbirth...that a natural childbirth is less expensive than a medical one, yet our system pushes medicine and doctors and a less natural experience of birth. The thing is, as I mentioned in your last post, that every woman is different and honestly, I am sure that Carolina would not have lived (umbilical cord was around her neck), and Sofia may not have made it either, had we not been in a hospital, with a lot of medical intervention and surveillance. The other bit is that of our system...a big issue that you have been tracking down all year. The thing is that if our government has been hijacked by corporate bodies (which I believe it has), then our political actions are serving to make money, not take care of citizens. The French paradigm with job security, financial support, and five (!) days in the hospital to recover and rest sound like a utopian dream compared to our system, where a mother can be discharged a single day after delivering a baby, with very little education or practical guidance. It does feel that we have very much gotten away from the wisdom of the ages, that Bill so impressively continues to perpetuate. Great post, really interesting.
What is DSP?
I would love more exploration of what it is to "dis-empower", vs. simply not having empowerment as related to motherhood and the birthing experience.
You wrote three highly detailed birthing posts. I found them all interesting but the first one was the zinger! Bill Hill is not your run of the mill midwife. I think your best line(and there were several of these)was, "When Bill speaks about the birthing of his wife he said,'she just pushed it out, but I did most of the work', when previously he had stated that if there aren't complications all there is to do is catch it. I believe such contradiction and prejudice towards the strength of his wife comes from the fact that she left 3 weeks after the birth of their second daughter." Its as though his wife said to him, "You did all the work so you keep them." It seems really tragic that she left him and her two babies. I'm sure has a point about hospitalsbeing a sometimes negative part of the "birthing industry." On the other hand, if there are complications, it's obviously better to be in a hospital. Even in this country, when a lot of poor people had babies at home, a lot of the mothers and babies died. The section about your own birth in France was really interesting too. My mother wishes she could have had my brother and me in France. The services are so good. She was lucky that she worked for the French American Foundation here when my brother was born and had a year of paid maternity leave. I think you wrote the way you talk, and this makes the writing lively. You just need to edit it more and I think you meant "relevant" when you said of "prevalent."
ReplyDeleteEloise,
ReplyDeleteI believe that your writing is in many ways informative. Your post had a lot of information from both Ryan's and Bill's interview that I forgot to add which shows me that you were able to listen well and jot down the notes at the same time- which is great! (I'm not so good at multi-tasking)
I also noticed that your writing is extremely straight forward which is good- it gets to the point.
I think that my favorite lines were when you explained WHY something was the way it was. It showed that the interviewer gave off one of their "bubbles" and you expanded off of them into real, thoughtful, thinking, which is great. I think that was my favorite line:
"This symbolized for me the ultimate women’s empowerment her being the center of attention because of her struggle in her most animal form naively being, not restricted by the pressures of society, with as many people as she desired supporting her."
I thought it was powerful, thought- provoking and insightful.
Although your writing was informative, I found it overwhelming to read simply because there was a lack of space within the actual format. I find that when you space out your writing into more paragraphs grouped together, its much easier to read and flows much better.